CO closing opposition
whip
motion:
THW allow inmates to pay to improve their imprisonment conditions
society
victim
inmates
other inmates
//governement side
PM:
p1:
bad condition can't punish them.
p2:
africa and india can't afford paying
greater chance to change
p3:
hui group feel abuse.
can change financial condition
aim:
dark house, give change to work,
create a circumstance to change by money from hardworking
not worker, they will not obey you
DPM:
rebuttal:
- belong to different people
inmates are different
can't be put into same prison - kill people should be shot immediately
can't be educated
points: - want them to be punished
different people has different path
rich people will not feel the same to before, can't get back to normal path
rich people should be also rich in prison? - relieve the financial burden of prison
member:
rebuttal:
will not let them luxuary life
condition may be messy and dirty
allow them to have private space
A:
why should they pay?
- may cause conflict:
solve by policy
don't money directly
use part of money to improve the whole !!
A:
complain not come from poorness, but from you are rich and I'm poor
whip
rebuttal:
- just improve their basic part of their living condition
- prevent from bullying, some punishment outside the sentence, some extra punishnimnet
- improve the whole condition, not just one by one.
///
my partner:
rebuttal:
- don't give policy how to pay
- it's not a special pheonomon only in prison, it's normal mental condition
points: - harm to the poor inmates
- unfair to poor inmates
poor inmates
treat equally, will make their anti-society more sever
and rich inmates - unfair to the victim
their punishment depends on what they have done, not how much money
//
clash:
whether they can get educated?
whether it's fair?
// opposition
LO:
rebuttal:
more wealthy inmates
provide other meats for hui group
p1:
just enjoy material life, can't realize mistake
can't be educated, can't concentrate on education
p2:
make a mistakes, let them suffer to educate them
imaginary situation:
the mother of victim can feel fair for her son
p3:
worsen relation between inmates
who are rich
divide them
contradiction between inmates
DLO:
rebuttal:
- will not cause burden on their life
points:
- bad environment will
right to be the normal people
difference between outside and inside
what they have done in the prison can change its life
- break the equality between inmates.
can't educate them better
